Bexley Pizza Plus Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the menu at Bexley Pizza Plus, located at 2651 E Main St Columbus, OH 43209, where pizza lovers can indulge in a variety of flavors. Reviews rave about their delicious pizzas, especially the meatball sub and specialty pizzas like the Mega Meat. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere with easy parking adds to the charm of this Bexley favorite. Customers appreciate the friendly staff, ample toppings, and thicker crust compared to other Columbus-style pizza places. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheese pizza or a unique combination like sausage and pineapple, Bexley Pizza Plus delivers with a smile. This spot on the Columbus pizza trail is a must-visit for anyone craving quality pizza in a laid-back setting.
Salads
Caesar
romaine lettuce, roma tomatoes and shaved parmesan
Greek
romaine lettuce, feta, green olives and roma tomatoes
Chef
iceberg lettuce, provolone, mozzarella, pepperoni, black olives, pepperoncinis and roma tomatoes
Deluxe Chef
iceberg lettuce, colby, provolone, mozzarella, bacon, chicken, black olives, roma tomatoes and pepperoncinis
Side Salad
iceberg lettuce, roma tomatoes and pepperoncinis
Party Salad
choose from chef, greek or caesar. (feeds -)
Choice Of Dressings
italian, light italian, honey french, buttermilk ranch, greek, blue cheese, caesar, balsamic vinaigrette and fat-free raspberry vinaigrette
Maximum Pep
a heavy combo of two types of pepperoni, margherita & mini
Six Cheese
provolone, mozzarella, swiss, colby, shaved parmesan and romano
Margherita
roma tomatoes, fresh garlic and fresh basil
All American
ground beef, bacon and your choice of colby or swiss
Hawaiian
colby, canadian bacon and pineapple
Cajun
cajun chicken breast, green peppers, onions, & sundried tomatoes
Greek
artichoke hearts, black olives, sun-dried tomatoes and feta
Lorraine
spinach, bacon, onion and swiss
Mega Meat
mini pepperoni, ground beef, chunky sausage and bacon
Three Mushrooms
blanched, fresh white and portabella mushrooms and either feta or extra cheese
Ultimate
blanched and fresh white mushrooms with pepperoni and mini pepperonis
Chicken Cacciatora
chicken breast, green peppers, onions, fresh garlic and roma tomatoes
Farmer's Market
spinach, broccoli, fresh white mushrooms, roma tomatoes and feta cheese
Primavera Plus
artichoke hearts, spinach, roma tomatoes, fresh garlic and fresh basil
Veggie
blanched mushrooms, green peppers, onions, roma tomatoes and extra cheese
Supreme
pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, green peppers, onions and extra cheese
Mexican
black olives, onions, mexican beef or mexican chicken, roma tomatoes, jalepeno peppers and colby cheese
Speciality Red Pizzas
Speciality White Pizzas
White
our garlic white sauce with provolone and mozzarella. add your favorite items
Chicken Broccoli
chicken breast, broccoli & asiago cheese
Steak Portabella
shaved prime steak, portabella mushrooms, carmelized onions, extra cheese and fresh basil
Philly Steak
shaved prime steak, mushrooms, green peppers and onion
Chicken Florentine
chicken breast, spinach, fresh mushrooms, shaved parmesan and fresh basil
Veggie Blanco
artichoke hearts, green peppers, fresh white mushrooms, black olives & roma tomatoes
Meats
anchovies, bacon, canadian bacon, chicken breast, ground beef, mexican beef, ham, meatballs, pepperoni, mini pepperoni, sausage, chunky sausage, salami, cajun chicken breast, shaved philly steak, mexican chicken breast
Veggies
artichoke hearts, black olives, broccoli, spinach, fresh garlic, fresh basil, green peppers, hot peppers, jalapeno peppers, onions, pineapple, roma tomatoes, sun-dried tomatoes, sliced tomatoes, pepperoncinis, blanched mushrooms, fresh white mushrooms, portabella mushrooms
Cheese
extra cheese (prov/mozz mix), colby, feta, shaved parmesan, swiss, asiago
Create Your Own Pizza
Subs
" Italian
ham, pepperoni, salami and provolone with lettuce, tomato, hot peppers and italian dressing
Super Italian
our italian sub with double meat and cheese
Veggie
mushrooms, green peppers, onions and provolone with lettuce, tomato, hot peppers and italian dressing
Meatball
italian meatballs, vine-ripened marinara sauce, provolone and spices
Ham & Cheese
ham and your choice of provolone, colby or swiss with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
Turkey & Cheese
turkey breast and your choice of provolone, colby or swiss with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
Chicken
two grilled chicken breast with provolone, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
Chicken Parmesan
two grilled chicken breast, vine-ripened marinara sauce, provolone and spices
Club
turkey breast, ham, salami, pepperoni, bacon and provolone with lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing
Steak & Cheese
shaved philly steak and your choice of provolone, colby or swiss with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
Original Pizza Sub
our vine-ripened marinara sauce with provolone, mozzarella, pepperoni and spices. served open-face
Greek Pizza Sub
our vine-ripened marinara sauce with provolone, mozzarella, artichoke hearts, black olives, sun-dried tomatoes, feta and spices. served open-face.
Garlic Bread With Cheese
our italian sub bun covered with a fresh garlic spread, provolone, mozzarella and spices. served open-face add a side of our vine-ripened marinara sauce
Cheesecake
served by-the-slice
Cookies
fresh baked chocolate-chocolate chunk cookies with macadamia nuts