Welcome to Bexley Pizza Plus
Bexley Pizza Plus, located in Columbus, Ohio, is a beloved pizza spot offering a variety of delicious options. With a focus on traditional flavors and generous portions, customers rave about their signature pizzas like the Mega Meat and unique toppings like sausage and pineapple. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere and friendly staff make dining in or taking out a pleasant experience. The menu also features tasty hot subs, cheesy garlic bread, and affordable lunch specials. Overall, Bexley Pizza Plus stands out for its quality, friendly service, and flavorful pizzas that keep customers coming back for more.
-
2651 E Main St Columbus, OH 43209 Hotline: (614) 237-3305
Located in Columbus, Ohio, Bexley Pizza Plus is a cozy pizza joint that has been a favorite among locals for years. Offering a wide range of toppings and specialty pizzas, this small, no-nonsense restaurant provides a casual and family-friendly dining experience.
Notable for their thicker crusts than most Columbus Style places, Bexley Pizza Plus delivers on flavor and quality. Customers rave about their delicious pizzas, hearty subs, and flavorful garlic bread. The Mega Meat pizza is a fan favorite, along with the variety of combinations available for pizza toppings.
The friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a great place for lunch or dinner. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheese pizza or looking to try something new like the chicken florentine pizza, Bexley Pizza Plus has something for everyone.
With easy parking, outdoor seating, and the option for delivery or takeout, Bexley Pizza Plus is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the Columbus area. Don't miss out on this gem on your next pizza adventure.
After returning to Bexley after 10 years, I had a yearning for pizza. This was my go to spot when I lived in Bexley. I called for delivery, smallest pizza with pepperoni, meatball and carmelized onions. I remembered to ask them to slice it like a pie and not in little squares. I also got a hot sub for my dinner the next day- Meatball parm. Both the pizza and the sub were soooo good. I'll be ordering from them often.
Had an amazing experience at Bexley Pizza Plus, tonight. Ordered a meatball sub, over the phone, easy, friendly service. Picked up in about 10 mins on a Saturday evening. Food was spectacular, portion was large, sauce was so good. Pizza is good but don't sleep on the subs!
Small pizza shop with a wide array of toppings. We enjoyed the cheesy garlic bread, sausage and pineapple pizza, plus a chicken florentine. Having the variety of flavors worked well. I'm glad i decided to stop here on my pizza trail!
A Bexley original and always a great lunch. Pizza and sandwiches always delivered with a smile. Seems that most people do carry out but decent dining room. Service is no frills but hospitable.
Thicker crust than most "Columbus Style" places. Good pizza, super friendly staff. Good stop on the Columbus pizza trail. Got the kids the basic cheese (Not the 6 cheese), they loved it
BPP has Bexley's best pizza, which is a tough call because Rubino's - another Bexley icon- is right next dOor. We like the easy parking, the casual family-friendly dining (small, no-nonsense) and of course the specialty pizzas. Mega Meat is our favorite, but they have about 12 that are great combinations. The salads are easy to throw-in so you feel a little healthy.
I LOVE pizza and try to get to as many different places as I can! I drove out to Bexley to give this pizza joint a try. It did not dissapoint! I just gota small pepperoni pie and I loved it. It Putney in the mind of the pizza you get at a fair, but even better. Good in its own unique way. Can't wait to go back.
Today went for lunch. I ordered the 8" one topping pizza with a beverage for $5.50. The pizza was ready when I got there, although I was probably 3minutes late. The taste was good and there was ample amount of the one topping.